So, it is the end of the year and I am reflecting on the interactive notebooks that we used this year. Honestly, I felt the stress of trying to keep each student (and myself) on the same page of each notebook. At the beginning of the year, I wanted to have every student on the same numbered page with the same notes on that page. However, that did not happen and it was very stressful for my OCD self! So, I gave up with the strict organizational method and just had each student take notes on whatever the next page was in their own, individual notebook. So, what started out as a nice, organized Interactive Notebook, was not as fun as I thought and it was not really very "interactive" as I had imagined. It ended up just being a notebook with note in it. We did tape some of our things in them, but overall, it was still just a notebook with notes. It makes me sad now that I think about it, but it did make the class a lot less stressful and it allowed each student to feel less stressed as well.
Here are some of the fundamental problems with the strict rules that I put on my interactive notebooks using the Cornell Method of note-taking:
1. Each student writes bigger/smaller than another one. Since the Cornell Method calls for certain notes on certain sides/sections of the notebook, if a student's writing is too large, they won't be able to fit all the notes in the particular section. This stresses the student out. Then, the student raises their hand and asks what they should do. What should they do? I am honestly not sure and that is one flaw for using the Cornell method with middle school students.
2. The next issue with this method that causes an issue is that every single lesson may not lend itself to this method of taking notes. While a lesson should have certain components, this method feels too rigid for me. It forces me to feel like I have to create certain components that may not really work well with the lesson for that day. While this might be a good method for other subject areas or even certain ELA lessons, I don't plan to use this method next year because it just felt too rigid for me.
3. At the end of the day with Cornell Notes, the method calls for a question or reflection after the lesson. In order to check these, I would have to take up the entire notebook. While this doesn't seem like much for one notebook, it gets crazy when you are checking 30 plus notebooks. It is nearly impossible to tote these home to grade. I always feel like it is semi-pointless if you can't at least look at what the students are doing.
4. Students just do not listen and follow directions perfectly. Therefore, this method will not work flawlessly because if a student does not get the right notes on the right page, then their notes are not just the same as the teacher's and other student's.
Next Year:
Next year, I get to teach with another teacher. Usually I am the only ELA teacher for 7th and 8th grades, but I get to share the 7th grade with my best friend this coming year. Together, we have decided to use a 3-ring binder. This was after some feedback from our students who say they like being able to put pages into the rings without destroying the notebook or without getting it out of order. I like this idea, too. Also, though, I like the idea of a composition book to put journals and other writings in. I think if they put all of their writings in one bound notebook, they will be able to keep up with these and they will be able to easily look at the past writings. I intend to use dividers for them to separate their work because I hand out a lot of things and it actually took up a lot of our class time for students to cut and paste/tape these things into a bound composition book. The divider tabs will have: article of the week (aow), notes, texts/things we are reading, vocabulary, and misc.
I think having a bound notebook for just writing that is not turned in will be beneficial and I am excited for this! Maybe I can come up with a cute, catchy name for this notebook as well! I hope to have students decorate the front like we did this year. We will create characters for narratives and begin brainstorming in our writer's notebooks (the bound ones). We will also practice writing in these and write things that are considered practice things in them. Anything that we have to turn in for a grade will be written on paper that can be turned in easier.